Blog Post

Dirty Profit?

Glen Burrows • 14 March 2025
Food is sold for profit so why is it a hard thing for some purpose driven farmers aim for?

"Just like music or painting, farming is an art whose product touches your soul. But if your farm goes out of business, there isn't any art at all"


Miyoshi Nakamura, Natural Agriculture farmer and teacher, Japan

Quote from: "Farming to Create Heaven on Earth" by Lisa M. Hamilton



Why is profit a dirty word in purpose driven businesses?


In purpose-driven businesses, profit is often seen as a dirty word because it has historically been associated with exploitation, unchecked capitalism, and short-term gain at the expense of people and the planet.


This perspective emerges from a mindset that values community, fairness, and sustainability above individual accumulation. It reacts against an earlier, more mechanistic worldview that measured success primarily through growth, efficiency, and financial gain—one that optimised systems for economic expansion, often at the cost of social and ecological wellbeing.


From this vantage point, profit can appear as a zero-sum game, where one party’s success must come at another’s expense.


Profit is regeneration


However, as our understanding of complexity deepens, we recognise that profit is not inherently exploitative; it is an essential flow of energy within any living system. In nature, a healthy ecosystem does not merely sustain itself—it generates surplus, which enables growth, resilience, and regeneration. Likewise, within a business or organisation, profit is the surplus energy that allows the mission to continue, evolve, and expand its impact. Without it, even the most purpose-driven initiative risks stagnation, dependency, or collapse.


Holistic Financial Planning


This is precisely why Holistic Financial Planning takes an entirely different approach to conventional budgeting. Instead of treating profit as whatever is left over after expenses, it begins with a fundamental question: "How much profit do you want to make?"


This shifts the focus from passive financial management to proactive financial design. By establishing a target profit figure at the outset—one that aligns with the holistic context, ensuring the business remains financially, socially, and ecologically viable—the entire financial plan is then reverse-engineered to achieve this outcome.


Rather than starting with expenses and hoping that income will cover them, Holistic Financial Planning prioritises revenue-generating activities first, ensuring that income is consciously structured to meet essential costs while securing a predetermined level of surplus. This approach transforms profit from an uncertain byproduct into a deliberate outcome, allowing for strategic reinvestment in the health of the business, the people involved, and the ecosystems it depends upon.


Designing for profit and regeneration


By designing financial plans in this way, profit ceases to be a mechanism of extraction and instead becomes a regenerative force—one that funds resilience, innovation, and long-term impact. The key is intention: when profit is consciously planned and aligned with a broader purpose, it enables businesses to thrive without compromising their values. The question is not whether profit should exist, but how it is pursued and to what end. It is not profit that corrupts, but the unconscious frameworks that wield it without regard for the whole.


Rather than rejecting profit outright, a more integrated perspective sees it as a tool—not the purpose itself, but a necessary function that enables sustained contribution. When cultivated through conscious structures, profit ceases to be a mechanism of extraction and instead becomes a regenerative force. It funds resilience, innovation, and the ability to give back in ways that create lasting change. The question is not whether profit should exist, but how it is pursued and to what end. It is not profit that corrupts, but the unconscious frameworks that wield it without regard for the whole.



Our course on Holistic Financial Planning Book a call to learn more
by Glen Burrows 14 March 2025
At its core, Holistic Management is about making decisions that align with long-term ecological health, economic viability, and social well-being, no matter where on earth.
by Glen Burrows 14 March 2025
Complexity creates stability in community dynamics
by Glen Burrows 14 March 2025
Could this be a new way of considering profit generation?
by Glen Burrows 6 March 2025
The Sun’s Gift: Energy Flow and Holistic Management in Ecosystems
by Glen Burrows 6 March 2025
The Furnace That Powers Life on Earth
by Glen Burrows 6 March 2025
How sunlight gives us fibre
by Glen Burrows 4 March 2025
Image: The youngsters at Sailean - Picture credit Alison
by Glen Burrows 28 February 2025
'The Best of British' collaboration is born.
by Glen Burrows 28 February 2025
How ancient Amazonian farmers mastered the Mineral Cycle and what we can learn from them
by Glen Burrows 28 February 2025
The Mineral Cycle: A Gateway to Understanding Holistic Management Following on from last week's look at the water cycle we now dive into the mineral cycle and see how they are related.
More posts
Share by: